Main Street Grill & Bakery

Located in the heart of Afton, NY, Main Street Grill & Bakery is a vibrant bar & grill and bakery hotspot that masterfully blends the comforts of classic American cuisine with imaginative, upscale twists. This inviting restaurant offers an extensive menu that caters to a wide range of palates, boasting everything from succulent seafood and hearty sandwiches to fresh, crisp salads and irresistible homemade desserts.

The culinary offerings here are genuinely impressive, with standout dishes such as the Maryland-Style Crab Cakes, tender Rack of Lamb, and the beautifully glazed Mango Mustard Salmon—each plate bursting with flavor and expertly prepared. For those craving savory sandwiches, the Main Street Philly Cheese Steak and the Main Street 8 Oz Cheese Steak Burger deliver an authentic, juicy experience, while the vegetarian-friendly Vegetable Panini provides a fresh, wholesome option.

Salads at Main Street Grill & Bakery are not mere afterthoughts but vibrant creations packed with organic baby field greens and fresh, local produce. The Oriental Crispy Chicken Salad, with its harmony of almonds, mandarin oranges, and a zesty sesame orange vinaigrette, is a crowd favorite, thanks to its lively blend of textures and tastes. Meanwhile, the Down on The Farm salad offers a creamy garlic dressing that perfectly complements its bounty of vegetables and feta cheese.

No visit would be complete without sampling the tempting starters: the Main Street Grill Zingers—crispy chicken strips tossed in bold Buffalo sauce accompanied by house-made blue cheese—offer a delightful contrast of heat and creaminess. The Pan Seared Pot Stickers, served with a sweet and spicy plum sauce, are a testament to the kitchen’s ability to blend unique flavors seamlessly.

But perhaps the true jewel of Main Street Grill & Bakery lies in its desserts. Reviews rave about slices of Coconut Cream Pie and Cannoli Cake that delight dessert lovers with their rich, indulgent textures and homemade wholesomeness. Brenda Karika praised the coconut cream pie as “homemade heaven” and “the best they’ve ever had,” perfectly capturing the essence of the bakery’s sweet offerings, while other patrons marvel over the breadth and quality of the baked goods that keep them coming back for more.

The atmosphere is warm and bustling, evoking an urban vibe that is both lively and welcoming. It’s the kind of place where locals and travelers alike find comfort in hearty meals and friendly service. Regulars appreciate attentive staff like Alex, who goes the extra mile to make every guest—and even their service dogs—feel at home. The only hint of busy energy can be the vibrant buzz during peak hours, an understandable sign of this popular spot’s well-earned reputation.

In sum, Main Street Grill & Bakery is a true culinary gem in Afton that combines quality, variety, and a welcoming ambiance. Whether you’re passing through or a local seeking a reliable favorite, the restaurant’s commitment to fresh ingredients, generous portions, and memorable flavors promises a dining experience that leaves a lasting impression.